147 The Very Bad Doctor

SURREY, BRITISH COLUMBIA

Additional content warning: this episode includes mention of intimate partner violence, suicidal ideation, and grooming and sexual assault of an underage person. No graphic details will be given. Please take care when listening.

A doctor repeatedly and intentionally betrays his oath to do no harm, setting off a chain reaction that escalates to murder. 

More info:

• Fatal Prescription: A Doctor Without Remorse, written by John Griffiths & Shelly Charalambus

Canadian True Crime donates monthly to help those facing injustice.

This month we have donated to the Canadian Resource Centre for Victims of Crime, who offer support, research and education to survivors, victims and their families.

Listen ad-free and early:
CTC premium feeds are available on Amazon Music (included with Prime), Apple Podcasts, Patreon and Supercast, giving you access 24 hours early without the ads. Please note: case-based episodes will always be available to all, we will never put them exclusively behind a paywall.

Credits:
Research by Eileen Macfarlane
Additional research, writing, sound design, narration: Kristi Lee
Audio editing and production: We Talk of Dreams
Production assistance: Jesse Hawke
Script consulting: Carol Weinberg
Disclaimer voiced by Erik Krosby

Music credits:
Theme songs (intro & outro) by We Talk of Dreams
Additional music: Blue Dot Sessions 

RESOURCES AND INFORMATION SOURCES

COURT DOCUMENTS:

• R. v. West, 1997 CanLII 3157 (BC CA), retrieved on 2023-10-22

• R. v. Charalambous, 1997 CanLII 3363 (BC CA), retrieved on 2023-10-22

• Charalambous v. College of Physicians & Surgeons of British Columbia, 1987 CanLII 2845 (BC SC)

• Charalambous v. Canada (Attorney General), 2016 FCA 177 (CanLII), retrieved on 2023-10-22

• Charalambous v. Canada (Attorney General), 2009 FC 1082 (CanLII), retrieved on 2023-10-22

• Josephakis Charalambous v. Attorney General of Canada, 2017 CanLII 1337 (SCC), retrieved on 2023-10-22

• Charalambous v. Canada, 2004 FC 4 (CanLII), retrieved on 2023-10-22

• Charalambous v. Canada (Attorney General), 2015 FC 1045 (CanLII), retrieved on 2023-10-22

BOOK:

• Griffiths, John. Fatal Prescription: A Doctor without Remorse (pp. 220-221). John Griffiths. Kindle Edition. 

Charalambous trial:

• newspapers.com/clip/108676169/  

• newspapers.com/clip/108676533/ 

• newspapers.com/image/495062648/?terms=%22david%20schlender%22%20&match=1 

• newspapers.com/image/503112505/?terms=%22sian%20simmonds%22

• newspapers.com/clip/108676590/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108676233/

• newspapers.com/image/502864889/?terms=Monjjyet%20Nareg&match=1&clipping_id=109118778

• newspapers.com/image/495062648/?terms=%22david%20schlender%22%20&match=1

• newspapers.com/clip/109416926/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/109409289/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/109118836/ 

• newspapers.com/article/the-vancouver-sun/109416926/

• newspapers.com/clip/109419758/  

• newspapers.com/article/the-vancouver-sun/109420130/

• newspapers.com/article/the-vancouver-sun/109424939/

• newspapers.com/image/503113819/?terms=%22katie%20simmonds%22&match=1 

• newspapers.com/article/the-province/108676129/

• newspapers.com/article/the-province/133386086/

• newspapers.com/image/503112505/?terms=%22sian%20simmonds%22

• newspapers.com/image/503113499/?terms=%22sian%20simmonds%22&match=1

• https://www.newspapers.com/image/503112961/

• newspapers.com/image/503113567/?terms=%22sian%20simmonds%22&match=1 

• newspapers.com/image/495592841/?terms=%22brian%20west%22&match=1

• newspapers.com/image/495593033/?terms=%22brian%20west%22&match=1

• newspapers.com/image/495593393/?terms=%22brian%20west%22&match=1 

• newspapers.com/image/495595082/?terms=%22brian%20west%22&match=1

• newspapers.com/image/495586521/?terms=%22brian%20west%22&match=1 

• newspapers.com/image/495586782/?terms=%22brian%20west%22&match=1 

• newspapers.com/clip/109424939/

• newspapers.com/clip/109424975/ 

• newspapers.com/image/494943656/?clipping_id=108671752&fcfToken=eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJmcmVlLXZpZXctaWQiOjQ5NDk0MzY1NiwiaWF0IjoxNjk3MjI4OTYwLCJleHAiOjE2OTczMTUzNjB9.6gJjsOKXFyIWhIgHm5-u3sScdEHEnw67GynN9PVcDpE

• https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-vancouver-sun/109468141/ 

Shelley testimony

• newspapers.com/clip/108722042/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/109423156/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/109422941/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/109422820/ 

Schlender testimony 

• newspapers.com/clip/109469079/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108676303/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108676422/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108676470/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722086/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722094/ 

• PRESS, FROM CANADIAN. "Doctor tells murder trial he was trying to scare sisters." Hamilton Spectator, The (Ontario, Canada), November 4, 1994: A9. NewsBank: Access World News 

• PRESS, FROM CANADIAN. "'Nothing to offer' police in slaying, MD says." Hamilton Spectator, The (Ontario, Canada), November 5, 1994: A9. NewsBank: Access World News. 

• MERTL, STEVE. "Doctor charged in murder of patient who complained." Kingston Whig-Standard, The (Ontario, Canada), November 5, 1994: 5. NewsBank: Access World News.

AFTERMATH OF CHARALAMBOUS TRIAL

• Day parole granted for man who arranged to have B.C. sisters murdered in 1993 | Vancouver Sun 

• newspapers.com/clip/108676653/

• newspapers.com/clip/108722928/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722134/ 

Charalambous was sentenced to life in prison and began his sentence in 1994.

• Charalambous v. Canada (Attorney General), 2009 FC 1082 (CanLII)

• newspapers.com/clip/108722137/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722143/ 

Public inquiry rejected 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722156/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722180/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722197/ 

Removed from medical register 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722783/ 

Charges dropped for procuring

• newspapers.com/clip/108722812/ 

TRIAL - WEST

• newspapers.com/clip/108722763/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722778/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722796/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722834/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722843/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722847/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722860/ 

Chris calls for an inquiry again Nov 1995 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722896/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722909/ 

SEXUAL ASSAULT CHARGES STAYED

• newspapers.com/clip/108671956/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108675631/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108723003/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108723057/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722812/ 

CHARALAMBOUS APPEALS

• newspapers.com/clip/108722963/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722993/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108723035/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108723044/

• newspapers.com/clip/108722943/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722982/ 

• Jones, Natasha. "Faint hope clause legislation won't impact Langley girl's killer." Langley Times (British Columbia, Canada), June 9, 2009: 4. NewsBank: Access World News. 

• CAVEAT STOPWATCH - March 1995 

Day parole granted 2016 

• https://infoweb.newsbank.com/apps/news/document-view?p=AWNB&docref=news/15CDD3C538393810. 

Denied parole, May 2020

Summary articles 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722098/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722108/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722115/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722122/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108722125/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/109469095/ 

• PRESS, FROM CANADIAN. "Doctor found guilty in patient's murder Judge hands him two life sentences." Hamilton Spectator, The (Ontario, Canada), November 30, 1994: A4. NewsBank: Access World News.

• CP. "DOCTOR GUILTY OF MURDERING EX-PATIENT//FAMILY JUSTICE." Toronto Sun, The (Ontario, Canada), December 1, 1994: 64. NewsBank: Access World News.

• Former Coquitlam doctor, karate instructor denied parole for murder-for-hire - Tri-City News 

About CAVEAT:

• newspapers.com/clip/108675852/

• newspapers.com/clip/108671873/the-vancouver-sun/ 

• newspapers.com/clip/108671379/ 

• CAVEAT STOPWATCH - March 1995